Australia urged to remove religion from terrorism definition in major legal review
A national security watchdog recommends excluding religion from the federal terrorism definition to prevent false credibility and reduce discrimination against religious minorities.
By Amir Bennett ·

The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor has recommended that Australia remove religion from its statutory definition of terrorism. The report, released on Thursday, argues that the current legal framework grants accused terrorists a form of false credibility while negatively impacting social cohesion, particularly for religious minority groups.
Jake Blight, the head of the monitor, stated that requiring proof that terrorists were advancing a religious cause reinforces their own narrative that they are performing holy work. He suggested that such individuals should instead be described as violent ideologues. This change aligns with international best practices and follows a recommendation from a United Nations special rapporteur earlier this year, who noted that references to religion in terrorism laws often have discriminatory effects that outweigh their benefits.
The current federal criminal code definition requires agencies to prove that an act intends to cause serious harm to advance a political, religious, or ideological cause. The new report proposes reclassifying religion as an example of a broader ideology category. This shift is intended to address the growing complexity of the threat landscape, where motivations behind attacks are increasingly difficult to categorize into single ideologies.
Aftab Malik, Australia’s special envoy to combat Islamophobia, supported the removal of religion as a primary motivation in his submission to the monitor. He argued that keeping religion in the definition creates a climate of suspicion around Muslims and provides ammunition for far-right extremist narratives. Eleven Muslim advocacy groups, including the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network, welcomed the recommendations and urged the government to amend the laws accordingly.
However, the proposal has not been universally accepted. Peter Wertheim, co-chief executive of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, described the report as high-quality but expressed concern that removing religion as a motivating factor makes little sense given that many notorious terrorist acts feature religious motifs and doctrines. He noted that faith is distinct from religion and that it is not appropriate for the law to determine which beliefs are authentic expressions of a religion.
In addition to redefining terrorism, the report includes six other significant recommendations. One key area involves the sentencing for credible threats of terrorism. Under existing laws, a person guilty of making such a threat can face life imprisonment with a mandatory minimum of six years. The monitor called this punishment disproportionate and recommended that threats be treated as a separate charge with a maximum sentence of no more than five years.
The legislation monitor also suggested raising the threshold for designating damage to property or electronic systems as acts of terrorism. Furthermore, it recommended explicitly excluding advocacy, protest, dissent, and industrial action from the definition to ensure that normal civic activities are not misclassified.
These recommendations arrive as security agencies warn of a changing threat environment. Mike Burgess, the director-general of the Australian Security and Intelligence Organisation, has highlighted the rise of violent nationalist extremism. In an October submission to a parliamentary inquiry, Asio noted that approximately 65% of its counter-terrorism caseload related to religiously motivated violent extremism, while 35% related to ideologically motivated extremism.
The review marks a significant moment in the 25-year history of Australian terrorism laws, which were originally introduced following the September 11 attacks in the United States. The findings aim to modernize the legal framework to better reflect current security realities and international standards.






