Curbs on Satellite Access Costing Ukrainian Lives, Carney Warns
Canada's Prime Minister links recent civilian casualties to a dispute over control of a critical satellite network.
By Amir Bennett ·

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney stated on October 23 that restricting Ukraine's access to a military satellite network is having lethal consequences. Speaking in Istanbul, he questioned the judgment behind the decision to limit the system's capabilities for a nation facing what he termed "naked aggression." The comments came amid confusion over who ordered the restrictions and whether they remain in effect.
Since early October, Ukraine has been unable to use certain features of Starshield, the military version of the Starlink satellite system owned by SpaceX. Ukraine relies on Starshield to track incoming missiles and jet-powered drones, and to guide its own interceptor and spy drones. A separate system, Starlink, handles the country's internal communications.
The cause of the access limits is disputed. A report from Reuters, citing two U.S. officials, indicated the order originated from within the White House. A Wall Street Journal report suggested Elon Musk issued the directive personally. Musk has stated that Starshield is controlled by the U.S. government and that decisions on restrictions are ultimately made by the U.S. military and President Donald Trump. Trump has denied ordering the curbs and, when asked on October 23, would not say who was responsible.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy reported that the curbs have prevented his country from tracking drones and missiles traveling faster than 160 kilometers per hour. He stated this has complicated the defense against Russian attacks and has led to civilian deaths, including children. Carney linked such outcomes directly to the restrictions, stating it "does seem clear" they have "real consequences, human consequences," and that some recent fatalities were direct casualties from this reduced capability. He referenced an attack in central Kyiv within the past 36 hours as an example.
Conflicting statements about the system's status persist. On October 22, Trump said Musk had restored Ukraine's access. However, Zelenskyy later told CNN, "it still doesn't work." Ukrainian military officials also confirmed on October 23 that the restrictions remain in place. In a separate interview, Zelenskyy said his government believes the American government sent a message to limit the system's speed, which SpaceX then implemented.
The issue arises amid strained relations between Kyiv and Washington. Trump is pushing for Ukraine to accept concessions in a peace deal and has also urged it to cease strikes on Russian oil refineries. Those drones do not use Starshield, as the system does not operate over Russian territory.
Carney connected the situation to Canada's own strategic planning. He said that depending on an ally "that may change their view" creates risk for Canadians. This realization is prompting decisions to diversify partnerships and build sovereign capabilities, he noted, adding that it will take time as Canada is "highly, highly reliant on certain systems in certain countries." Zelenskyy is pursuing a similar path, having signed a letter of intent with Finnish companies Nokia and ICEYE on October 22 to develop a Ukrainian satellite communications network.
The dispute over Starshield access highlights a broader tension between allied nations and private technology companies over control of critical military infrastructure. Ukraine's efforts to build an independent system signal a potential shift in how nations manage the technology that underpins modern warfare.






