Understanding the International Court of Justice and its role in global disputes
Following a significant ruling on the Rohingya genocide case, an overview of the ICJ's history, jurisdiction, and limitations in international law.
By Amir Bennett ·

The International Court of Justice, commonly referred to as the World Court, issued a verdict on Thursday declaring that Myanmar committed genocide against the minority Muslim Rohingya population. This decision has drawn renewed attention to the institution's function, composition, and the scope of its authority within the global legal framework.
The court serves as the highest judicial body of the United Nations for settling disputes between states. It is distinct from the International Criminal Court, which focuses on prosecuting individuals for war crimes. Established under the 1945 UN Charter, the ICJ was created to provide a permanent venue where nations can resolve legal disagreements through international law rather than through the use of force. The institution held its first session on April 18, 1946.
While all 193 member states of the United Nations are eligible to bring cases before the ICJ, only 75 countries have filed specific declarations that grant the court immediate jurisdiction when a dispute arises. Additionally, the court holds jurisdiction over disputes concerning the application of more than 300 international treaties, which includes the 1948 Genocide Convention. UN bodies, such as the General Assembly, may also request advisory opinions on questions of international law. Although these opinions are not legally binding, they often carry considerable weight in subsequent proceedings in national courts.
The court is headquartered at the Peace Palace in The Hague and is composed of 15 judges who serve nine-year terms. Rulings delivered by the ICJ are binding on UN member states and cannot be appealed. However, the court possesses very limited mechanisms to enforce its decisions, relying largely on its moral authority. Consequently, rulings are sometimes ignored by the parties involved.
The docket of the ICJ includes a wide variety of disputes, ranging from land frontiers and maritime boundaries to hostage-taking and genocide. In recent years, the court has increasingly accepted cases involving allegations of state violations of human rights. Currently, one third of the cases on the court's docket deal with such allegations.
The institution made headlines in 2023 when South Africa brought a case against Israel, accusing it of committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. While the court issued several emergency measures in that matter, the main arguments are not expected until late 2029. Israel opposes the case but maintains that it respects international law. Another high-profile case concerns the war in Ukraine. Following Russia's full-scale invasion in February 2022, the ICJ ordered Moscow to immediately suspend military operations the following month. As with the South Africa case, there has been no final ruling in the Ukraine dispute either.
These ongoing cases highlight the evolving role of the ICJ in addressing modern conflicts and human rights issues. The court's decisions continue to shape international legal standards, even as debates about enforcement and jurisdiction persist among member states.






