Florida Prosecutors Detail Case of British Woman Allegedly Lured to US and Murdered
Prosecutors in Ocala have presented evidence that an auto repairman lured a woman from England to Florida, where she was allegedly killed and buried in a shallow grave.
By Carolina Barrett ·

Prosecutors in Ocala, Florida, have presented a detailed account of a criminal case involving Dwain C Hall, an auto repair and tow truck driver. Hall is accused of kidnapping and murdering Sonia Exelby, a woman from Portsmouth, England. The state alleges that Hall lured Exelby to the United States before killing her in October 2025 and burying her remains in a shallow grave at Marion Oaks. Hall has entered a plea of not guilty to the charges.
The disappearance of Exelby from her home in England triggered an international investigation. During court proceedings this week, prosecutors outlined the background of the victim, noting that she suffered from mental illness. Investigators stated that after Hall was arrested in November 2025, evidence showed Exelby had traveled to Florida following an online post in which she expressed a desire for someone to end her life.
According to the arrest affidavit, Exelby had previously expressed suicidal thoughts. Investigators allege that Hall was aware of her struggles and exploited her vulnerability to bring her to Florida. Authorities described how Exelby boarded a flight to the US with the apparent intention of being possibly sexually abused, tortured, and murdered by unknown individuals in the country.
After arriving in the United States in October 2025, authorities say Hall picked Exelby up from Gainesville airport in central Florida. He drove her to an Airbnb rental where investigators later discovered evidence linking him to her disappearance and death. This evidence included transactions on Exelby's bank cards and a video of her found on Hall's cellphone.
A text message sent from Exelby's phone to a friend provided further insight into her state of mind. In the message, she described feeling scared and trapped. She wrote, "I'm sorry, he keeps taking my phone, he doesn't trust me with it," and added, "He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him."
Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt provided opening statements in court, explaining that Exelby's parents had struggled with mental illness and addiction. Berndt noted that Exelby herself had a history of mental health issues and had attempted suicide twice. The court heard that Exelby had visited a website depicting graphic sexual abuse of women, where Hall was one of several men who contacted her.
Berndt stated that Exelby was seeking a substitute for self-harm and that she ultimately found another outlet. The prosecutor described Exelby as "trying to find someone who would kill her" and remarked that there was "no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and vile ways possible."
Following her disappearance, a former boyfriend named Stevie Hunt contacted authorities. In court, Hunt described Exelby as a kind, beautiful, and loving woman. Her sister also spoke to the court about their difficult childhood. Hunt noted that Exelby experienced mood swings lasting for days and had been in therapy for more than a decade.
While Hall has denied killing Exelby, he acknowledged in a police interview that he had been in contact with her and that they had been intimate. Physical evidence linking Hall to the crime includes a shovel bearing Exelby's blood, cellphone data, and a knife recovered from a friend of the defendant. Prosecutors indicated that jurors would view photographs and surveillance video of Hall purchasing items such as rope, a shovel, and deodorant at a local Walmart.
Defense attorney Junior Barrett argued in his opening statement that his client was not a murderer. He asked jurors to carefully consider the facts, witness testimony, and circumstances. Barrett stated, "We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder." The case is ongoing.






