Susan Smith Denied Parole for Second Time in 1994 Case
A South Carolina woman convicted of drowning her two young sons in 1994 was unanimously denied parole again on Thursday, 32 years after the tragedy.
By Carolina Barrett ·

Susan Smith, now 55, has been denied parole for the second time in connection with the 1994 drowning of her two young sons. The decision came on Thursday after a hearing before the South Carolina Board of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services, which unanimously voted to keep the convicted murderer in prison.
Smith was originally convicted of strapping three-year-old Michael and one-year-old Alex into their car seats and rolling their vehicle into a lake. During the recent hearing, she described the moment the car entered the water as her lowest point, stating, "I got to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake."
The board required two-thirds of the members present to vote in her favor for release, but the request was rejected. Smith’s legal team had argued that she suffered a mental breakdown at the time of the crime, a claim she supported by telling the board she has changed and matured significantly since the incident. She also expressed that she was "very, very sorry."
David Smith, the father of the boys, continued his long-standing opposition to her release. Speaking at the previous hearing in 2024, he argued that thirty years in prison was not a severe enough punishment for the loss. He noted that this equates to only fifteen years per child, asserting that it was simply not enough time for a mother to spend behind bars for her own sons.
During the original trial, prosecutors presented a narrative that Smith killed the children after a man with whom she was having an affair told her they were the reason they did not have a future together. However, at Thursday's hearing, Smith challenged this theory. She stated, "This did not happen because of a man. That's just not true."
When the children first disappeared, Smith claimed she had been carjacked late at night and that a man had driven away with her vehicle. She publicly pleaded for their safe return while the boys were actually at the bottom of a nearby lake. Although she initially maintained this story, she eventually confessed to the crime.
Defense lawyers during the trial suggested that Smith had intended to die with her children but left the car at the last minute. Under South Carolina law applicable at the time of her conviction, she became eligible to apply for a parole hearing every two years after serving thirty years in prison.
In the United States, parole allows individuals convicted of crimes to be released from incarceration before completing their full sentence. Smith can continue to apply to the state board for parole every two years. Several individuals spoke against her release during the Thursday hearing, reinforcing the board's unanimous decision to deny her freedom.






