AdvertiseDonate
LatestThree Arab men shot dead in Israel within a single day
☰ SectionsWhat’s happening across America.
World Newz Live · 11799 Sebastian Way, #103, Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730

ICJ verdict on Myanmar reshapes genocide law and signals path for Israel case

The ICJ's historic ruling against Myanmar for genocide provides a new legal framework that is closely being monitored for its impact on the ongoing case against Israel.

By Amir Bennett ·

Illustration for: ICJ verdict on Myanmar reshapes genocide law and signals path for Israel case
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The International Court of Justice has delivered a historic verdict by finding Myanmar guilty of committing genocide, a determination that marks the first time any nation has been held responsible for the crime under international law. The ruling, issued by a panel of judges in The Hague, not only offers a measure of justice for the Rohingya victims but also revitalizes the 1948 Genocide Convention as a governing framework for state actions. By establishing a detailed roadmap for applying the convention to real-world scenarios, the court has provided crucial guidance on how to assess the intent behind governmental atrocities.

The decision was reached by a nine-to-six majority, a narrow margin that indicates the complexity of the legal arguments presented. This lengthy judgment is expected to be studied closely by Israel, the only other country currently facing genocide accusations before the ICJ. It also carries significant implications for Germany, which has been brought before the court by Nicaragua on charges of facilitating and failing to prevent genocide in Gaza.

Legal experts have described the ruling as a turning point for humanitarian law. Philippe Sands, a leading human rights lawyer who was part of the Gambian legal team, stated that the judgment brings the Genocide Convention alive, giving it practical meaning rather than leaving it as a dead letter. Agnès Callamard, secretary general of Amnesty International, characterized the decision as a rare moment of justice for survivors and their families, while also noting its importance in asserting humanitarian law in a world that often feels lawless.

Dr Iva Vukušić, an assistant professor in international history at Utrecht University, emphasized that the ruling is a good day for international law. She noted that the judgment clarifies many legal standards, which will be helpful for future cases. The decision is also expected to influence the International Criminal Court, another tribunal based in The Hague, by providing a benchmark for when genocide charges might be brought against individual perpetrators.

The US administration, which has historically shown hostility toward international legal institutions, has been watching the proceedings critically. The US ambassador to the UN previously warned the court against lowering the legal threshold for proving genocide, fearing it could be weaponized against American and allied soldiers. However, the court did not lower the existing standard; it maintained that genocidal intent must be the only reasonable inference from the evidence. Instead, the judges focused on clarifying how this standard applies to state committed atrocities.

In assessing the Myanmar campaign, the court looked beyond the death toll of approximately 10,000 people. It considered the total Rohingya population in northern Rakhine state, which numbered 815,000. The judgment also accounted for mental damage to survivors, particularly victims of sexual violence, and the impact on the community's reproduction. This broader approach contrasts with previous cases, such as those involving Serbia, where the focus was narrower.

A key legal distinction in this judgment is that other motives, such as the desire to displace or punish a population, can exist alongside genocidal intent. The court ruled that genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference from the totality of the evidence against Myanmar. This interpretation is significant for the ongoing Gaza case, which is currently hearing written pleadings and is expected to take at least three more years to conclude.

The court highlighted several factors relevant to the Gaza situation, including the targeting of children. The judgment noted that up to 2,109 Rohingya children under the age of five were killed, a statistic that parallels the more than 5,000 Palestinian children under five killed in the Gaza war. The court described this targeting as striking at the foundation of the group. Additionally, the judgment cited bulldozing and large-scale terrain clearance followed by rapid construction of security installations, a pattern observed in the Israeli army's occupation of over 60 percent of the Gaza Strip.

William Schabas, an international law professor at Middlesex University, commented that the judgment is full of messages for Israel. He noted that while the evidence in each case will differ, the structural similarities are stark. If one were to exchange the word Myanmar with Israel, he suggested, the core of the judgment would remain largely applicable. This view has raised expectations for how the court might interpret evidence in the South African case against Israel.

Despite the strong majority, the presence of six dissenting judges indicates that the reasoning was not without dispute. Lawyers involved in the case have cautioned that this ruling does not guarantee that the same bench will find Israel guilty. However, they added that the opposite is likely true, arguing that if the Myanmar case had failed, the case brought by South Africa against Israel would have been all but over. The verdict thus serves as a critical precedent for future proceedings in The Hague.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get World Newz Live in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get World Newz Live in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.