AdvertiseDonate
LatestThree Arab men shot dead in Israel within a single day
☰ SectionsWhat’s happening across America.
World Newz Live · 11799 Sebastian Way, #103, Rancho Cucamonga, CA 91730

Pressure mounts on Burnham to adopt universal political donation cap

Peers and experts are urging the government to replace the complex overseas donor limit with a universal cap on all political donations as the elections bill approaches the House of Lords.

By Youssef Carter ·

Illustration for: Pressure mounts on Burnham to adopt universal political donation cap
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Calls are intensifying for Prime Minister Andy Burnham to commit to a comprehensive cap on all political donations as the elections bill moves to the House of Lords. Critics argue that the current proposal, which limits only overseas donors to 100,000 pounds, is overly complicated and fails to address the broader issue of mega-donations. There is growing uncertainty regarding whether the 72 million pounds in recent donations received by Reform UK will be subject to these new restrictions.

David Blunkett, a former Labour home secretary and current peer, has tabled an amendment advocating for an overall cap. His proposal suggests an annual limit of 500,000 pounds per donor. This approach is believed to have broad support among various members of the Lords. Other amendments currently under consideration range significantly in their proposed limits, with figures varying from 1,000 pounds to 5 million pounds per year.

While No 10 had previously promised a taskforce to examine wider caps on donations, senior government figures prefer to address this through new legislation in the next parliamentary session. This strategy aims to avoid delaying the current bill, which is facing complex amendments. Additionally, the Labour government is still working to overcome opposition from trade unions, who worry that universal limits could reduce their influence.

Experts are urging the government to replace the specific overseas donor cap with a blanket cap for all donors to prevent potential loopholes. The overseas cap was announced in March and is intended to apply retroactively from that date. This timeline could impact Reform UK, which received 36 million pounds from crypto billionaire Ben Delo and a further 36 million pounds from Christopher Harborne this autumn.

Reform UK has stated it will not return the funds and plans to challenge the law's retrospective application in the courts since the legislation has not yet passed. Delo's donation is less likely to be affected because he has long been registered to vote in the UK. In contrast, Harborne's donation is more contentious as he was previously an overseas elector and only registered to vote in Britain in June of this year.

Some officials are concerned about the prospect of a judicial review regarding the retrospective nature of the legislation. The House of Lords constitution committee noted that this aspect has not been sufficiently justified and could set an unwelcome precedent. However, government sources maintain that retrospective legislation is not new and has multiple precedents under successive administrations to prevent immediate evasion of new rules.

New government amendments to the bill aim to tighten the overseas donor cap by introducing complex rules around donations held in trusts and as loans. These changes also require formal declarations about residency to identify which donations may need to be returned. Rose Zussman, a senior policy manager at Transparency International UK, argued that if a cap is appropriate for overseas donors, it should apply to all.

Zussman noted that the current amendments acknowledge that unlimited donations risk democracy but stop short of the obvious solution. She stated that singling out one group of donors risks appearing partisan and makes complex rules harder to follow. She emphasized that a universal cap is the simpler answer and one that the public overwhelmingly supports.

Susan Hawley, director of Spotlight on Corruption, agreed that an overall cap would be simpler and more effective. She described the bill as becoming insanely complex with nearly 180 government amendments, making it difficult to navigate and enforce. Hawley criticized the government for disregarding public mood by failing to introduce spending limits and a donation cap to remove big money and undue influence from party funding.

Stella Creasy, the Labour MP who proposed the 100,000 pound cap in the Commons, argued that separate legislation would be too late. She stated that if there is concern about billionaires buying the next election, the issue must be addressed at the source. She expressed surprise at the strength of feeling in the House of Lords regarding the influence of wealthy donors with UK postcodes. Despite previous support from Burnham, trade unions have pushed back against the idea, fearing that a future right-wing government could use the cap to limit their contributions. Shaun Bowler, founder of WakeUpGB, said he felt Burnham had broken a pledge when the government declined to back a general cap. He argued that the solution is to introduce the same fair limit for everyone, including unions, rather than preserving enormous donations on both sides.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get World Newz Live in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get World Newz Live in your inboxWhat’s happening across America. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.