Appeals court upholds charges against Rep. LaMonica McIver over ICE detention center visit
A federal appeals court has denied Rep. LaMonica McIver’s bid to dismiss charges stemming from a confrontation outside a New Jersey immigration detention center, setting the stage for a likely trial.
By Amir Bennett ·

A federal appeals court ruled on Thursday that Democratic Representative LaMonica McIver will continue to face criminal charges related to a confrontation outside an immigration detention center in New Jersey last year. The court declined to overturn a previous ruling that had allowed the case to proceed, effectively ending McIver’s immediate efforts to dismiss the charges before a full trial.
The decision comes just one day after McIver engaged in a heated public exchange with Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin. During a House committee hearing, McIver criticized the Trump administration’s aggressive immigration enforcement operations, telling the secretary, “You are killing people.” With the court’s latest decision, the representative is now facing a probable trial for the incident that occurred in May 2025.
In a statement issued on Thursday, McIver expressed her frustration with the outcome. She stated, “Because of a weaponized Department of Justice, and because I dared to do my job and conduct oversight of ICE, I am facing 17 years in prison.” She added that the third circuit’s decision brought the country closer to a world where the president could imprison individuals simply because he dislikes their political stance.
The legal battle began last year when McIver was charged with assaulting, resisting, impeding, and interfering with federal officers. She has consistently argued that the prosecution is a political attack by the Trump administration. In August, the third circuit court of appeals rejected her arguments that the constitution protected her from prosecution. On Thursday, the full bench of active judges denied her request for an en banc hearing, refusing to reconsider the decision made by the three-judge panel.
The incident originated during a congressional oversight visit to the Delaney Hall detention center, a large Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in New Jersey. Last May, McIver arrived at the site accompanied by two other members of Congress and Newark Mayor Ras Baraka. The group was barred from entering the detention center, leading to a standoff outside the facility.
According to a declaration from a Homeland Security agent, a federal officer attempted to arrest Mayor Baraka for refusing to leave the premises. McIver intervened in an effort to prevent the arrest. Federal officials claim that during the ensuing confusion, McIver slammed her forearm into a Homeland Security agent and forcibly struck another deportation officer with her forearms.
McIver noted that she is the only elected representative currently facing charges for the scuffle, as the charges against Mayor Baraka were previously dropped. She stated, “I hope that everyone who feels that way will stand with me in my fight against these unjust charges, because while I am the first lawmaker they have tried to jail, I will surely not be the last.” Her legal team is now exploring all available options for the next steps in the case.
The Delaney Hall facility has faced repeated scrutiny since it resumed detaining immigrants arrested by ICE in 2025. At least three individuals have died while detained at the facility. It was also the site of significant clashes with ICE earlier this year during protests supporting a hunger strike led by detained immigrants.
During Wednesday’s hearing with Secretary Mullin, McIver highlighted the conditions inside Delaney Hall and the number of deaths in ICE custody. She reminded Mullin, “As you know, I am facing 17 years in prison, from this Trump administration, for my work at Delaney.” She asked if he understood why she had been sounding the alarm about the facility for so long.
Mullin responded by stating that he had visited Delaney and that the facility was in very good condition. McIver challenged this assessment, telling him, “History is going to judge you for what you are doing.” Mullin dismissed her claims as false, but McIver reiterated her statement that the administration was killing people, underscoring the tension between the lawmakers and the executive branch over immigration policy.






